Shalimar Cologne against Eau de Shalimar
One number per era rather than one number overall — two fragrances can be
near-identical at the opening and different things by the evening, and an
average hides exactly that.
How close, and when
Across a whole wearing, Guerlain Shalimar Cologne and Guerlain Eau de Shalimar are all but the same thing. They are nearest during the opening and furthest apart in the drydown, which is the part a single figure would average away.
98%
opening · 0–1 h
94%
heart · 1–3 h
91%
drydown · 3–8 h
- At the opening, 0 to 1 hour in, the two are all but the same thing.
- At the heart, 1 to 3 hours in, the two are all but the same thing.
- At the drydown, 3 to 8 hours in, the two are all but the same thing.
Measured across all twenty-four facets, from the notes below — not from the
families on the boxes. They share
5 of 13 materials, which is
worth holding beside the figures: a pair can share almost nothing and still
converge, because different materials can smell of the same things.
What AKIN predicts
AKIN predicts these two are alike, and the evidence behind that is substantial.
Two signals sit on this page and are never averaged: what the note
pyramids measure these two to share, and what AKIN’s resemblance
graph predicts. Where they part, that is the finding rather than a fault.
The pyramids, side by side
Compared by material rather than by spelling, so a note recorded two ways is
not counted as a difference.
top
both — Bergamot, Lime
Shalimar Cologne only — Grapefruit, Lemon
Eau de Shalimar only — Orange
heart
both — Jasmine, Rose
Shalimar Cologne only — Freesia
base
both — Vanilla
Shalimar Cologne only — Orris, White Musk
Eau de Shalimar only — Iris, Resin
Other comparisons worth reading
Pairs involving one of these two where the notes are fully recorded on
both sides and AKIN has enough evidence for the pair to be worth reading.